The Coffee Potter

About Us

The Coffee Potter has the kind of energy people remember, a cozy spot where the pace feels easier the moment you walk in. With a 4.8-star rating from 795 reviews, it has clearly become a favorite for regulars and first-timers alike, drawing people in for a reliable cup, friendly service, and a setting that feels welcoming without trying too hard.

Located at 24 Schooleys Mountain Rd in Long Valley, this coffee shop fits naturally into the daily rhythm of the area. Guests often pair a visit with time outdoors, a quick stop on the way through town, or a slower morning that deserves something better than rushed coffee. The atmosphere is relaxed, the team is known for being kind, and the whole experience has the feel of a place that knows its community well.

From the first sip to the last minute at the counter, The Coffee Potter delivers the simple pleasures that matter most, good coffee, an easygoing setting, and the kind of local charm that makes people come back.

What We Offer

At The Coffee Potter, the focus is on making your coffee stop feel easy, satisfying, and worth repeating. Whether you are starting early, taking a break mid-day, or swinging through Long Valley on your way somewhere else, this is the kind of place that keeps things smooth and inviting.

Along with coffee, guests can enjoy a café-style experience that suits both quick visits and longer stays. The space is a natural fit for people who want a comfortable place to slow down, catch up, or simply enjoy a well-made drink in a friendly environment.

With a strong local following and a reputation built on consistency, The Coffee Potter is the sort of neighborhood stop people recommend because it feels familiar fast. It is a dependable choice for anyone who wants quality, warmth, and a coffee shop that feels genuinely connected to Long Valley.

Why Choose Us

4.8-star rating from 795 reviews shows consistent customer satisfaction and strong local trust.

Open 7 days a week with early morning hours, making it easy to fit into busy routines.

Located on Schooleys Mountain Rd in Long Valley for a convenient stop close to town life.

Known by visitors for a cozy atmosphere and friendly service that keeps people coming back.

A well-loved local coffee shop that has built a loyal following over years of steady visits.

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

⭐ Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

4 months ago

"I love the The Coffee Potter! It’s such a cozy and welcoming environment. I like to walk the trail near by and stop in for a coffee after. It can get busy but everyone is so nice especially the girl with the red hair ! She works really hard and always makes a great coffee. Definitely recommend there’s places to sit and the vibe is 10/10"

— Abigail Sanborn

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

3 weeks ago

"First time here and what a wonderful place to visit! It was dog friendly, had a drive thru and had some outdoor seating. The girls were very sweet inside too plus the coffee was delicious!"

— Erica LD

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

4 months ago

"I’ve been coming here for years, and they hands down have the best coffee in town. Their food is also amazing, I especially love their burritos and chocolate chip cookies. The employees are friendly, and the atmosphere is very inviting. Will definitely keep coming here!"

— Sam Hunt

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

4 months ago

"Cool little coffee shop with a drive-through. The interior has a couple of rooms to hang out in, pretty cosy. The staff are friendly and chill. This is right next to the Columbia Trail so you can incorporate it into a hike or bike ride."

— S D

⭐⭐⭐⭐

a month ago

"I really like this place. The vibes are great! Everyone is really nice. There are plenty of outlets and usually I can find a place to sit (though it does get really busy sometimes.) There is a nice walking trail right there too. One thing: I wish they would introduce some vegan things to the menu. I would give it 5 stars if there was any food for me to eat :)"

— Allison Rowley